Does Asperger's syndrome really exist?

Page 3 of 4 [ 56 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

sinsboldly
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 21 Nov 2006
Gender: Female
Posts: 13,488
Location: Bandon-by-the-Sea, Oregon

26 Nov 2009, 3:57 am

Spokane_Girl wrote:
Did I read that right? Kids have to be taught to talk? I thought they learn on their own. That's what we all know. For them to learn, they have to be exposed to our language and they pick up on it and learn it.


Don't mothers go 'bobobobobo' and such to their babies to get the kid to make noises like mommy? That is what I mean by being taught how to talk. My mom did nothing of the sort with me. She said I was 'vaccinated by a phonograph needle' meaning I could mimic people I heard on the radio, or sing songs and commercial jingles when a baby (not a toddler) in my cradle.


_________________
Alis volat propriis
State Motto of Oregon


SpiritBlooms
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Nov 2009
Age: 67
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,024

26 Nov 2009, 3:34 pm

Spokane_Girl wrote:
Did I read that right? Kids have to be taught to talk? I thought they learn on their own. That's what we all know. For them to learn, they have to be exposed to our language and they pick up on it and learn it.
Well I have seen mothers, including my own mom with her grandchildren, when they see a child saying, "Uh!" and pointing to an object. The mother then coaxes the child to name the object. I would call that teaching language.

When I was in grade school, the structure of sentences and how words were used seemed second nature to me. I was way ahead in reading comprehension and grammar. I remember in 6th grade I was in a new school and, because I was horrid at sports and all the kids in the new school loved sports, they thought I was stupid. They even said so to my face. But when it came to grammar lessons, I did them so quickly it actually got embarrassing and I purposely slowed myself down, because I wanted to fit in. But it was agonizing, doing a grammar exercise slowly just so other kids wouldn't think I was weird. I could've gotten through the whole year's grammar lessons in one day. I remember being the only one who knew that one pronounces "the" differently before a vowel sound. I don't know how I knew it, or why I'd noticed it. I just knew, and it amazed me that anyone else could not have noticed. However, I've always been a slow reader. Maybe I unconsciously analyze sentences as I go.



88BK
Snowy Owl
Snowy Owl

User avatar

Joined: 5 Nov 2009
Gender: Male
Posts: 159

26 Nov 2009, 3:58 pm

zendell wrote:
I noticed most people who replied didn't even bother to read my post. So I'll summarize what I wrote. The study I posted found that everyone diagnosed with AS was misdiagnosed and had HFA instead because symptoms started before 2-3 years old.


haha i noticed that as well. it is a trend around here, people don't read, they post!

but anyways, i did read your post and think it's very interesting! i didn't think a study would have such results. i am around many people who have AS and HFA and i can see definite differences between them, they are subtle and internal, but they are there!

i would like to know what "type" of person qualified for a HFA diagnosis BEFORE AS existed (i was diagnosed HFA after AS came into the DSM), that might help explain why the felt the need to create AS. i mean why weren't all these asperger types simply being diagnosed as HFA? and if they are exactly the same, how come there are all these people who went undiagnosed for so many years? why aren't all the older self-diagnosed types running around saying "oh my life only started when i discovered HFA"?? they say Aspergers!!



makuranososhi
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 12 May 2008
Age: 47
Gender: Male
Posts: 5,805
Location: Banned by Alex

26 Nov 2009, 4:08 pm

Personally, I tend to refer to being on the spectrum as opposed to AS or HFA. As HFA is purported to have a language delay vs. AS, based on that criteria I would be considered AS - my initial language was somewhat confusing, but once I started reading heavily, most speech challenges were less severe (save for my pronunciation of "r" and "s" sounds). Given that it is a spectrum condition, that in any one individual there will varying strengths and weaknesses that result in pronounced difference in exhibition, it doesn't surprise me that there is a grey area between to such similar diagnoses. However, I really wonder why there is such furor over the definitions... it seems a somewhat self-serving topic to me.


M.


_________________
My thanks to all the wonderful members here; I will miss the opportunity to continue to learn and work with you.

For those who seek an alternative, it is coming.

So long, and thanks for all the fish!


wildgrape
Toucan
Toucan

User avatar

Joined: 28 May 2009
Age: 73
Gender: Male
Posts: 262

27 Nov 2009, 12:59 pm

88BK wrote

Quote:
i would like to know what "type" of person qualified for a HFA diagnosis BEFORE AS existed (i was diagnosed HFA after AS came into the DSM), that might help explain why the felt the need to create AS. i mean why weren't all these asperger types simply being diagnosed as HFA? and if they are exactly the same, how come there are all these people who went undiagnosed for so many years? why aren't all the older self-diagnosed types running around saying "oh my life only started when i discovered HFA"?? they say Aspergers!!


In the interest of informing the younger generation, I will take a stab at answering this.

The proliferation of psychologists is a relatively new phenomenon. When and where I went to school there were no psychologists in the whole school district, let alone employed by the school board. So no student was diagnosed with any condition, including HFA, and there was no special ed.

Moreover, at that time, autism was not a separate diagnosis in the DSM, but LFA was considered childhood schizophrenia. If I recall correctly (I read about this at one time), autism didn't enter the DSM on its own until 1984, although the term was in use before then. This means that the window between when autism (not HFA per se) was recognized and when asperger's was recognized is relatively narrow, so it is safe to assume that there were relatively few diagnoses of HFA. Since there has been a proliferation of articles about Asperger's over the last several years, many older AS learned about AS before learning about HFA.

My personal experience is a bit different. As a teen, I worked for a while in a small institution for "emotionally disturbed" children. It was a safe environment since victims of violence or sexual abuse were not accepted, so Social Services sometimes placed other special cases with us for a time. One of these was an adorable six year old non-verbal autistic boy. I was eerily drawn to him, and always "knew" that my behavior at his age resembled his, except my flapping was more continuous and pronounced and I was verbal. Over the years, I sometimes wondered if my "eccentricity" could be attributed to a neurological condition, but knew that I wasn't bipolar, schizophrenic, etc., and always came up empty. The FIRST time I read the words "high functioning autism", a shill went up my spine, and I immediately started seeking information and also found out about AS, as well. I never felt comfortable about the AS label for me because I was never the "little professor" type.

Now, I have a question for the younger generation. I frequently read here on WP of young people who have been diagnosed between the ages 15-22 years, and this puzzles me. There have been psychologists in all school districts for the past 25 years, it seems to me. How is it that so many are not recognized as autistic in the earliest grades, but are in later years? My autism was far more apparent when I started school that it was when I finished.



27 Nov 2009, 1:04 pm

88BK wrote:
zendell wrote:
I noticed most people who replied didn't even bother to read my post. So I'll summarize what I wrote. The study I posted found that everyone diagnosed with AS was misdiagnosed and had HFA instead because symptoms started before 2-3 years old.


haha i noticed that as well. it is a trend around here, people don't read, they post!

but anyways, i did read your post and think it's very interesting! i didn't think a study would have such results. i am around many people who have AS and HFA and i can see definite differences between them, they are subtle and internal, but they are there!

i would like to know what "type" of person qualified for a HFA diagnosis BEFORE AS existed (i was diagnosed HFA after AS came into the DSM), that might help explain why the felt the need to create AS. i mean why weren't all these asperger types simply being diagnosed as HFA? and if they are exactly the same, how come there are all these people who went undiagnosed for so many years? why aren't all the older self-diagnosed types running around saying "oh my life only started when i discovered HFA"?? they say Aspergers!!



At what age are aspies supposed to be showing signs by?

I was showing signs by age two. I am not sure about before. Doctors thought I was autistic.



Callista
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 3 Feb 2006
Age: 41
Gender: Female
Posts: 10,775
Location: Ohio, USA

27 Nov 2009, 1:09 pm

Well, my mom basically kept me from getting a diagnosis, though she knew it would have been simple for me to get one. We switched schools every year; and I don't remember being taken consistently to the same pediatrician, either. I was simply labeled rebellious, badly-behaved, (by the schools) spoiled, and either slow or too smart for her own good. My mom was frightened of the label, because to her autism meant a child who was non-verbal and in diapers and would never be capable of independence or a "normal life".

Actually, I think that's part of why the Asperger's diagnosis exists--to accommodate people who fit the symptoms, but not the stereotype, of classic autism. A specialist can feel comfortable diagnosing Asperger's in a child when a diagnosis of Autism would seem, thanks to that stereotype, to be either false or unwanted catastrophizing. Asperger's has a stereotype of the intelligent socially-delayed child. People are afraid of the stigma of autism; so they hedge their bets, say Asperger's, and never stop to realize that their problems would be solved if it became commonly known that autism is a spectrum, with a wide range of phenotypes.


_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com

Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com


bdhkhsfgk
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 May 2009
Age: 31
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,450

27 Nov 2009, 1:20 pm

Don't FLAME me for this, but I think people with AS have better speech than those with HFA, HFA speech can vary form childish to monotone like those with AS, that's an easy way to figure out if you have HFA or AS, but I can't recognize myself in anyone i've met with HFA, they either act like standard or happy 6-year-olds, almost copying their interest and behaviour pattern, when it comes to those i've met with AS, they show more interest in the world around them and act like christians, thye hardly smile, but act like a stereotypical poet or christian, or in a special case, rude.



Callista
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 3 Feb 2006
Age: 41
Gender: Female
Posts: 10,775
Location: Ohio, USA

27 Nov 2009, 3:39 pm

No, there's no flames for that; that is in the official criteria--Aspies have no speech delay. The problem is, Is this a fundamental difference; or are people just picking on one difference out of many to divide autistic people in an essentially arbitrary way? I think the latter. The differences between autistics with speech delays and autistics without are not great enough to justify an entirely different category. It's gotten to the point that it's based on nothing but stereotypes--lots of kids with speech delays are getting Asperger's diagnoses because they seem smart, so it becomes a self-perpetuating stereotype.


_________________
Reports from a Resident Alien:
http://chaoticidealism.livejournal.com

Autism Memorial:
http://autism-memorial.livejournal.com


Eggman
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Jul 2008
Gender: Male
Posts: 4,676

27 Nov 2009, 6:07 pm

yes


_________________
Pwning the threads with my mad 1337 skillz.


ShadesOfMe
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 30 Jun 2004
Age: 32
Gender: Female
Posts: 16,983
Location: California

28 Nov 2009, 12:06 am

I think it does, and is a form of HFA. HFA and As are very close together. and tend to mix.

I am, definitely an aspie. I had abnormal speech, but not delay. I learn to talk in my first few months, and scared the s**t out of people.