kraftiekortie wrote:
Do you believe Flemish is a separate language? Or do you believe it's a dialect of Dutch?
That's an interesting question. Officially Dutch is an official language of both the Netherlands and Flanders and it is considered a single language. But the standard Dutch is more or less a constructed language from all the regional languages/dialects, mostly based on what they speak in the western part. So when I listen to the Flemish news I can understand them just fine, though I needed to get used to the accent and to the few different words they use. I think this is similar to American or British English.
Then there are some Flemish people who speak in their regional dialect(or regional language, it's pretty arbitrary) and I can't understand any of it at all. But there are also people like that in the Netherlands. If people here speak in their regional language I can't really understand them, sometimes even if they try to speak standard Dutch I can't understand everything because of the accent.
Here is a really interesting picture in this article about Flemish on wiki (didn't want to post the picture because it's so huge):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flemish
The second picture has in yellow Nederfrankish (Low Franconian, which is Dutch) and green Nedersaksisch (Low Saxon) and Fries (Frisian) and Mittelfrankisch (Middle Franconian, which sounds close to German to me). Langues d'Oil is French.
The area was settled by different but closely related tribes such as the Franks, the Frisians and the Saxons (yeah, the ones who didn't go to England). Generally people in the non-yellow language areas such as Frisians also speak standard Dutch. I live on the edge between the yellow and green areas and there are people within a few kilometers of where I live that I can't understand it if they speak their regional language. So I think that the standard Dutch is one language that contains both what I speak and what they speak in Flanders, but the regional languages are seperate to me (including the regional languages in the Netherlands). I remember quite a few times talking to someone from a different part of the Netherlands in Dutch, and then they get a call from their parents and they switch to their regional language, and I only understand half of it. This language continuum continues into Germany. The north of Germany also has Low Saxon languages.