On punching Nazis

Post Reply New Topic

His viewing someone else as evil simply for belonging to a minority group is indefensibly wrong.

It is. I am not saying that it isn't I am saying it doesn't make him a bad person. He is doing what he thinks is right.

I don't believe right comes into the equation for those people. Rather, it's all about feeding their hate and prejudice. Right and wrong doesn't come into the picture for them.

Why exactly are you asking me? I have no control over laws, nor will I ever since I have no talent for or desire to be in law/politics. That would be a question to ask someone who could actually create a bill and get backing. Also said bill would never go through because the United States is an aggressive capitalist society and profit will always prevail over human rights. That's the nature of capitalism.

To answer your question there is no bill that can be passed unless we reject capitalism.

If you want to punish the capitalists that enslave you then opposing their policy of mass migration is step one, you can never collectively bargain with an infinite labor supply that makes workers totally worthless individually and it further gets better for them yet as they can(and have since the colonists started arriving on the continent) divide the workers against each other by race. They play on your emotions and manipulate you into thinking they are the moral ones but follow the money, they're not doing it because of anything besides money & power.

There's zero evidence that they wanted to murder anyone. Amazing how your double standards work. You realise the 'suspects' were at a barbecue or funeral and the other innocent people around them were blown up? I guess Arabs are all terrorists in your eyes though. Unless Trump is banning them. Wait, you're pro Israel?

You support racial apartheid, ethnic cleansing and mass murder so don't lecture me about nationalism. How many people has that Spencer guy killed? You support and vote for mass murderers.

Please don't make assumptions. I remember Chomsky talking about the subject. Though there are some Black Panthers who have called for white babies to be burned, so going by your rules that justifies randomly punching any of them.

To some it seems to be. Some of the people on here are supportive of ethnic cleansing, depending on who carries it out So having horrible views warrants a beating but criminals don't deserve to be shot? Just trying to work out your moral compass.

Not sure who coerces you to use these labels. I'm not alt right whatever that means.
You should win a gold medal in mental gymnastics though. I did nothing of the sort. Asking questions to test someone doesn't mean you hold those views.

All neo Nazis believe in racial supremacy, that's a fact.

Also shooting someone and punching someone are not the same thing so they aren't really comparable. And again, as I said, police are trained to non violently de-escalate as well. That is part of their job. A civilian punching a neo Nazi is not on the same level as a police officer shooting a criminal. And most of these shootings have not been criminals anyways so it's a moot point.

Sargon uploaded a video on this subject.

Yes it does just look at what those people say. They genuinely believe that Muslims are coming to Europe to destroy it and don't want to see it happen. I am sick of us generalizing the people of Stormfront they are people like us that deserve to be treated with respect.

You want to end discrimination the way to do it is by giving support to the people of West Virginia, Kentucky and Mississippi, it will eliminate the fundamental level of anger that leads to resentment against different peoples. If we don't do this than all hell could break loose, this is after all how Hitler came to power. The German people were angry over their inequality and with it those who they perceived as having had more.

I can't guarantee this will make most people change. But it will end the vicious cycle of hatred as their children will become less dissatisfied with the system and the anger will not get passed on.

How many actual neo Nazis are there in the US? And having that belief is hardly more dangerous than going around the world blowing people up for power, resources and money. Why not focus on the most serious problems. It's like how people focus on that church with 100 members that doesn't like gay people just because the ADL highlighted them. People throw these labels around too easily. Muhammed Ali believed black people were superior over whites, does that mean he was a neo Nazi?

I know I was just asking.

Most Nazis I have seen on Stormfront believe in doing what they feel is right. Do you have any evidence that they are evil?

I’m answering having just read the opening post and watched the video.

I’ve watched that video some days ago and already commented why I disagree with it on youtube.

Saying that his ideology is unacceptable and therefore it is justifiable and ‘okay’ to sucker punch that man is not right.
There are plenty ideologies that I think of as unacceptable and disgusting but that doesn’t give me the right to punch people who hold those ideologies, nor would I ever justify violent actions done by others against my political opponents.
Everyone – yes that includes Nazis – has the right of having their political opinion and stating that opinion without having their physical integrity threatened/taken and without being persecuted by the state or discriminated against by the law.
It is this man’s right to express his opinion but the other man has no right to punch him for it.

When you and that T1J guy together with many others say that it is “okay” to punch your political opponent and thereby violate his rights based on his political views and justify that with how unacceptable and disgusting you think his ideology is, then I’m sorry but that is nothing else but fascism!

This doesn’t have anything to do with defending Nazis. Heck, it isn’t even about Nazis.
It is about the entitlement of each individual to his own political opinion and freedom of expression.

However, let’s forget the question whether it is okay to punch your political opponents for a minute. Who do you think gained anything from that action? Who do you think this punch in the face helped?
It’s that little wanna-be Hitler and not the moronic dimwit who punched him in the face. He is probably happy that he has been punched.
He is the one who looks innocent in this scenario, he is the one who gains the victim points and he is the one who now gets the attention. This also made more people know who Richard Spencer is.
As a foreigner I’ve never heard of that guy before, I didn’t have a clue who this was. But when I saw a video of this incident, I asked myself:” Who is this man? Why did he get punched? Why are they calling him a Nazi?” And I did my researched on that idiot.

Anyhow, punching your political opponent is not okay. Don’t punch your political opponents, debate them, use facts, use arguments then you can win.
But by using violence against someone who didn’t use violence against you, you will cause damage to your own side and standpoint.

What do you think are the intentions of the Neo-Nazis? Tell me ONE good intention!! !

Nobody has the right to cold-cock a Nazi--but I certainty would feel the desire to do so in my mind. Their "ancestors" killer millions of people of many nationalities because of some notion of "Aryans" being superior or something.

This without Hitler, in any way, exhibiting "Aryan" characteristics.

Where did I or t1j say I support sucker-punching somebody?