The Bible
MarketAndChurch
Veteran
Joined: 3 Apr 2011
Age: 39
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,022
Location: The Peoples Republic Of Portland
the oral tradition is important as it "color's" the story and gives you perspective. (there are musical notes on every word in the Torah because there is no punctuation between the words, so it is sung to clue you in on where to stop, when to pause, when to emphasize a word, or clue you in om the importance (or non-importance) of something).
I can provide an example if you'd like.
_________________
It is not up to you to finish the task, nor are you free to desist from trying.
leejosepho
Veteran
Joined: 14 Sep 2009
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,011
Location: 200 miles south of Little Rock
Been there. Done that. Only made me have doubts about that supposedly loving and good God.
If God exists, It is Power. Do not confuse that with human love or kindness.
Power, love and kindness can all go together, and I have no problem seeing all of that in God ... and I have yet to ever see God either destroy or order the destruction of anyone exhibiting love and kindness.
_________________
I began looking for someone like me when I was five ...
My search ended at 59 ... right here on WrongPlanet.
==================================
Been there. Done that. Only made me have doubts about that supposedly loving and good God.
If God exists, It is Power. Do not confuse that with human love or kindness.
Power, love and kindness can all go together, and I have no problem seeing all of that in God ... and I have yet to ever see God either destroy or order the destruction of anyone exhibiting love and kindness.
Try Sodom. The men in Sodom loved each other's tooshies.
ruveyn
I think I can safely say that it is not a book that has been written for people to make sense out of. It reads more like it has been written to confound people.
The stories in it seem to range from epic war accounts to mundane soap saga's. There is magic and mystery mixed with practical guidence (for the bronze age at least).
When reading it I am quite shocked that these stories are promoted to children.
In a nutshel it appears the OT is a justification for war, pillage, and repression. While the NT starts off magical and kind of sweet, only to descend into a justification for pride and intolerance.
Am I being too critical? Am I missing something?
What does the Bible mean to you?
Much of what you've read is recorded as a history more than a "do this" lesson, and those were brutal times. To know where you are going you have to understand where you've been, as they say, and so history is an important part of the Bible. But it was oral history before it became written, and will have the alterations that follow from that.
Many of the Old Testament stories are about the little guy rising over the big guy because of the power and wisdom of God, and that message resonates with children. The stories do get reworded a bit for kids, though. Overall, it isn't that much different from the other material children read. Children read fantasy novels with war and violence, and study the holocaust in depth in middle school - along with Edgar Allen Poe. The world only really seems to want to shelter them from sex.
To me, the Bible is a combination of history and lesson, that was often written obscurely so that it could mean different things at different times, or to different people. I see it as a living book in that it seems to be able to adapt depending upon what a reader needs from it, and in that it seems to be able to find relevance in a world that has changed substantially since the time in which it was written.
I think trying to read it literally actually does a disservice to what God intended with it.
I think that many people incorrectly read it to justify things they want God to tell them, instead of what God is actually hoping to tell them. But knowing the difference, when you are being guided by your internal motivations instead of God's will ... that is tough, and so it is easy to use the book incorrectly. I think anyone using the Bible to justify a position or belief has to think long and hard about that possibility.
_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).
Been there. Done that. Only made me have doubts about that supposedly loving and good God.
If God exists, It is Power. Do not confuse that with human love or kindness.
Power, love and kindness can all go together, and I have no problem seeing all of that in God ... and I have yet to ever see God either destroy or order the destruction of anyone exhibiting love and kindness.
Try Sodom. The men in Sodom loved each other's tooshies.
ruveyn
The description in the Bible doesn't limit the sins of those living in the city to one act. And, in the story, God would have saved the city if a single "just" person could have been found.
_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).
Those damned Gamorreans tempted God's wrath
[img][800:800]http://images.wikia.com/starwars/images/6/64/Gamorrean-hd.jpg[/img]
_________________
Opportunities multiply as they are seized. -Sun Tzu
Nature creates few men brave, industry and training makes many -Machiavelli
You can safely assume that you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do
The description in the Bible doesn't limit the sins of those living in the city to one act. And, in the story, God would have saved the city if a single "just" person could have been found.
Ten righteous men. All the Away Team could find was Lot and his immediate family.
ruveyn
The description in the Bible doesn't limit the sins of those living in the city to one act. And, in the story, God would have saved the city if a single "just" person could have been found.
Ten righteous men. All the Away Team could find was Lot and his immediate family.
ruveyn
And they turned out to be incestuous.
I think I can safely say that it is not a book that has been written for people to make sense out of. It reads more like it has been written to confound people.
The stories in it seem to range from epic war accounts to mundane soap saga's. There is magic and mystery mixed with practical guidence (for the bronze age at least).
When reading it I am quite shocked that these stories are promoted to children.
In a nutshel it appears the OT is a justification for war, pillage, and repression. While the NT starts off magical and kind of sweet, only to descend into a justification for pride and intolerance.
Am I being too critical? Am I missing something?
What does the Bible mean to you?
Much of what you've read is recorded as a history more than a "do this" lesson, and those were brutal times. To know where you are going you have to understand where you've been, as they say, and so history is an important part of the Bible. But it was oral history before it became written, and will have the alterations that follow from that.
Many of the Old Testament stories are about the little guy rising over the big guy because of the power and wisdom of God, and that message resonates with children. The stories do get reworded a bit for kids, though. Overall, it isn't that much different from the other material children read. Children read fantasy novels with war and violence, and study the holocaust in depth in middle school - along with Edgar Allen Poe. The world only really seems to want to shelter them from sex.
To me, the Bible is a combination of history and lesson, that was often written obscurely so that it could mean different things at different times, or to different people. I see it as a living book in that it seems to be able to adapt depending upon what a reader needs from it, and in that it seems to be able to find relevance in a world that has changed substantially since the time in which it was written.
I think trying to read it literally actually does a disservice to what God intended with it.
I think that many people incorrectly read it to justify things they want God to tell them, instead of what God is actually hoping to tell them. But knowing the difference, when you are being guided by your internal motivations instead of God's will ... that is tough, and so it is easy to use the book incorrectly. I think anyone using the Bible to justify a position or belief has to think long and hard about that possibility.
But how should atheists read the bible?
AngelRho
Veteran
Joined: 4 Jan 2008
Age: 48
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,366
Location: The Landmass between N.O. and Mobile
Been there. Done that. Only made me have doubts about that supposedly loving and good God.
If God exists, It is Power. Do not confuse that with human love or kindness.
Power, love and kindness can all go together, and I have no problem seeing all of that in God ... and I have yet to ever see God either destroy or order the destruction of anyone exhibiting love and kindness.
Try Sodom. The men in Sodom loved each other's tooshies.
ruveyn
The description in the Bible doesn't limit the sins of those living in the city to one act. And, in the story, God would have saved the city if a single "just" person could have been found.
I think God DID momentarily spare the city. Perhaps Abraham was looking ahead to knowing Lot and his family were in or near Sodom and that was his primary concern. As long as Lot maintained his presence, God would have spared the city.
But Lot would not have been a righteous person had he disobeyed once he was told to leave. So he and his family leaves, leaving God no reason to continue to spare the city.
I've often wondered why it is this is an oft overlooked facet of the story when it is taught.
Ten righteous men. All the Away Team could find was Lot and his immediate family.
ruveyn
And they turned out to be incestuous.[/quote]
That was after the city was destroyed. Lot and his daughters holed up in Tzoar (Mrs. Lot had been solidified earlier). And the daughters, those lascivious vixens had to get the Old Man drunk first.
ruveyn
