simon_says wrote:
They could just write the pope and get a special indulgence, magically making the children legitimate through a dispensation.
Though that probably doesnt work any more and it might only be for wealthy nobles.
I dunno... I can't speak for Catholics. If you're going to base a personal lifestyle on New Testament morality, then you should be consistent. The Bible teaches that a man and woman living together should be married. Even from a stricter OT perspective, a man and a woman were encouraged to get married if they were already sexually active, and apparently sex between two people who were betrothed was frowned upon but also winked at.
Of course, I view marriage a bit differently than most people. I do see it as a formal binding contract with consequences for breaking its terms. Not to downplay the role of love, but it is only one comparatively small element of the relationship.
I see sex and even children as wonderful and good things that enrich the lives of married couples and parents. I identify as a conservative evangelical myself, and I see this issue as something my fellow evangelicals get dead wrong every single time. Don't tell an older teenager or young adult to wait for marriage, especially at the age they're going to enjoy intimacy the most and have the energy for parenting, and then turn right around and say "oh, btw, you have to wait another 15-20 years while evrybody else gets to have sex and you don't." You create a situation in which a young person is forced choose between compromising his morals and dealing with the guilt and possibly other damaging consequences OR completely missing out on many good things life has to offer.
I'm curious to know in, say, the next 8 years if there really are any guys (or girls) my age who are still unmarried virgins after signing virginity pledges because they're still wrapping up educational and career goals. I'd also like to know how many of them got married and were BOTH virgins on their wedding night. I'm all about teaching abstinence and the value of marriage and family. But those of us who do teach those things aren't looking at it very realistically. It's a special kind of hypocrite who encourages young people to be ambitious and live out their dreams AND practice abstinence and who themselves married early.
Heck, my own parents were high school seniors when they got married and they both managed to graduate from high school as a married couple. But I can't do that...I have to wait for after college? Redonkulous.