Prayer sessions at a public high school graduation?

Post Reply New Topic

I was torn. I didn't know weather to say "Yes", or to say "No, but as long as other religions are acknowleged and respected.".
I ended up voting for the latter, but I'm still somewhat torn- what does education have to do with religion anyways? Why should it be in schools at all?

But I voted for the latter, as people will do what they will. But if one religion is included, all should be. It is unfair and biased to do otherwise.

The high school I went to had a slight Christian overcoloring which always annoyed me.
I mean, we had wiccans. We had a bible study group, but no similar group for other religions. I remember that some of the wiccans tried to make a group and tried to have it approved. The principal denied it. No surprise.

I should have started a Buddhist group, but there probably would be so few people even interested let alone actual adherents that there would be no point in making it. I have a feeling the principal might have allowed a religious tollerance club. I should have brought it up. The problem is finding potential members and a teacher to sponser it. I know there was a Bible club and it had a weird name. Like Club 221 or something like that. I forget what the actual number was.
There seemed to be quite a few Wiccans at my school too, but I dont think they tried to make any group. They were all usually the "outcasts" and anti-socials. I think there were a couple jews, but everyone else was most likely either Christian/Catholic or Athiest. Those two made up the vast bulk.

Is it a private school? Then they can do whatever they please.

Is it a public school? If so, you should contact the ACLU, this has lawsuit potential.

I actually couldn't answer the poll, because none of the answers fit my position. Any student should have the right to organize whatever they like, so long as it does not have anything to do "officially" with any school function. If the school is involved in any way, or provides any funding, that is unacceptable.

I don't think we should have religious stuff in school. School is for learning not worship, and as there are likely to be a variety of beliefs among the students, it's not very appropriate.

Religious stuff at my secondary school was rare and met with controversy. At my primary school, it was quite Christian, we sang lots of hymns and said lots of prayers, and they brainwashed me and lots of other naive children into beliving in a God their families did not believe in. I don't know how those of different religions felt there. My guess is they didn't feel happy with it.

No, religion shouldn't be banned from public schools. My high school had the most wonderful Christian club that was (only slight pun intended..) a Godsend. We met every morning before school to pray, and I never could have gotten through without it.
But that was a voluntary group of students that wanted to meet to pray, not something everyone had to to. It's not something that should be done at events like graduations that include everybody. Prayer and Bible study were required to be student-run.