Have you read Stranger in a Strange Land?

Post Reply New Topic

If so, did you grok it?

I tried reading the original uncut version and got bored of everyone having sex with each other. I'd like to read the edited version though. More words doesn't equal better writing.

I grok.

It was grok.

Groking grok.

The most grokishly groking grok I have ever groked.

Grok?


PS: Thou art God.

I grokked it. I like the word "grok." I think it's a better book for an adolescent than an adult, though. I'm sure I'd have loved it at 11-14 years old, but having read it at 22(ish?), I was turned off by the sense of self-importance I got from the author. Didn't everyone already think the kinds of things the author was trying to get his audience to think on their own without aid of a book by the time they were a teenager, anyway? My friend who read this book at 30 (and is the one who reccommended it to me) disagrees with me, though. He suggested that perhaps not most people are big thinkers as children. Anyway, I liked the beginning, but cared for it less and less as it went on and it all seemed very obvious and un-clever.

Mostly I was left disappointed that such a fantastic title was used up by a not-so-fantastic book.

Read it, grokked it, bought copies and gave them away to other people so they could, too! I read it at the properly impressionable adolescent age, but thought it stood up to re-reading in my 20's. (I also couldn't stand the unedited version.)

I knew a couple of people who were involved in the Church of All Worlds back in the 1990s.

I only know that title as a song by U2 from the album "October".

in my teenage years i was interested in fiction for a while, and i read Heinlein voraciously. i really loved his work at the time.

Wanna read it.

And, don't worry guys! I am an adolescent!
I'm hardly ever interested in any literature aimed at my age group, however.

Yes, read it. Thought it was quite good but not great. Might see if I can find where I put it if I run out of other things to read.

Got it, but haven't grokked it. Lost in a haze. Don't know what to read.

I don't think that I'll be reading it. I'm too much of an innocent.

I must have read it as a very young adolescent, because I don't remember any sex at all.
I was inspired by it, mainly, I think, by the 'secret teachings' he received from the martian elders before he was sent back to Earth.
As a young aspy, I was glued to the idea that if only I could find out, or figure out, or discover the 'secret teaching'
I could fit in, be accepted, teach, be worshiped even, like he was.
It was a bit disheartening to realise I could never be raised by Martians, since I had already been born on Earth!


I devoured Everything Heinlein wrote, back then. Free Love, misfits coming of age and realising their potential.

It's not a good idea for aspies to read too much Heinlein, not when we're young, not like I did.
It gives us false hopes.