Page 2 of 4 [ 52 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

dianthus
Veteran
Veteran

Joined: 25 Nov 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,138

26 Feb 2014, 9:03 pm

Rocket123 wrote:
Sometimes my worry is related to sensory things. For example, I hate when my clothes are near their end of life as it's difficult to find things that are comfortable. So, I worry and stress until I find a replacement. This may take multiple trips to the store over multiple weeks. It may include multiple purchases, returns and more purchases. To, say, find a single pair of pants. So, I worry.


I do this too. I'm on a constant quest to find and replenish comfortable clothes. I buy and return a lot, and buy items in multiple quantities. Sometimes I buy items online in multiples when I'm not sure they will work and then have to drag the lot back to the store to be returned. I wonder if they dread to see me coming to the return counter.



Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

26 Feb 2014, 10:02 pm

zer0netgain – Thanks for your reply.

zer0netgain wrote:
You should tell her what you told us....that you are skeptical and want to be sure. She may be doing you a favor as if she sees no reason to disagree with the first Dx as she'd have to do a whole new workup to give a proper 2nd opinion. A medical doctor doesn't just take your lab results from the first doctor to give a second opinion. They should run their own tests...that takes time and costs YOU (and your insurance company) money. You could make it easier for her if you could ask her opinion on if she felt the evaluation done by the first doctor is spot on or if she has reason to disagree with it. Then, she's just reviewing the first doctor's evaluation for possible flaws/oversights.


Your advice makes sense. As I mentioned above, I did give her a copy of the diagnosis report. If she reads it (which I hope she will), I presume we would discuss it in our next session. If she doesn’t read it before the next session, I doubt that she ever will. In that case, I may just stop seeing her – simply out of principle.

As a note, I would not expect her (or anyone) to re-administer the battery of tests I took when I received my original diagnosis. I would not expect my performance to be that much different on the Psychologist-administered tests (i.e. WAIS-IV, WCST-R, WMS-IV, etc.). Likewise, I would not expect my answers to differ dramatically on the various questionnaires I completed.

zer0netgain wrote:
To some degree, she is correct. You probably DO need to work on it, but it should not be a higher priority that your concerns over your coping skills.

In therapy, YOU are supposed to be in control. She should respect that. Be open to working on social skills, but insist that she focus on helping you on areas you believe are more important. If she keeps shifting away from what you feel you need without a good reason, she's not listening to you.

I don't know anyone who will stick with a doctor that doesn't listen to their patients.


Makes sense.



btbnnyr
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 18 May 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,359
Location: Lost Angleles Carmen Santiago

26 Feb 2014, 10:22 pm

If the scores on the tests are the same and the answers to the questionnaires are the same, and this psych doesn't see a big difference in your behavior than the other psych, and of course your childhood history is the same, and so is your current life, then what is the point of another psych signing off on a second diagnosis when you already have a first diagnosis that was thorough and legit?

Are you worried that you are misdiagnosed or that you are not "autistic enough" based on what you read from other people on WP?


_________________
Drain and plane and grain and blain your brain, and then again,
Propane and butane out of the gas main, your blain shall sustain!


Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

26 Feb 2014, 10:41 pm

Dianthus – Thanks for your reply.

dianthus wrote:
It is really disturbing to me that she said that.

Yes it's true as others said, that you will be treating the same symptoms no matter what the label is, BUT the approach you take to understand and treat those symptoms may vary quite a bit depending on the diagnosis. If she does not think it would make any difference, that most likely means that she plans to treat any symptoms you present with in the same way, regardless of what condition you may have. I think that is a mistake. If you actually had another condition, the approach might need to be different.

Of course it is important to have the right diagnosis! If therapists only treated "symptoms" and treated all symptoms the same way there would be no need for any labels at all. There would be no need to diagnose anything. The diagnosis is important because it changes the approach for treatment. Duh! What is she thinking? This is so absurd to me it makes me angry on your behalf.


I agree. It was disturbing to me. I felt a bit disturbed when she said it. And, the more I think about it, the more disturbed I am.

It was almost as if all I need to do is repair my relationship with my wife and kids and everything will be solved. Or, maybe that will enable me to create better relationships with others. And, then everything will be solved. I don’t buy it. First, because my relationship with my wife and kids is not that bad. Are there problems. Of course, there are in every relationship (I presume). And, more importantly, my relationship with them is much better now than it has ever been.

As I think about it, I am beginning to wonder if a neurotypical Psychologist can really understand someone on the spectrum. While they can understand (at least from a text book perspective) how our cognitive processing is different, they cannot actually experience it. I am beginning to think that the only thing they can do, is to encourage us to become, well, more neurotypical. But, I don’t want that. I want help becoming more comfortable in my own skin.

dianthus wrote:
This also throws up a red flag to me: "That anyone, even someone with Aspergers could improve their relationships if they are motivated to do so." Even someone with Aspergers? if they are motivated to do so? It sounds almost like she has already made some kind of judgment on you, that you should be more motivated.


This bothered me as well. It’s almost as if “improving relationships” is this persons “go to strategy” for helping people. I am beginning to wonder if this whole thing is worthwhile.

dianthus wrote:
How did it go at the end? Did she outline a plan on how she wanted to proceed? Did you she ask what YOU think about her suggestions and how you feel about proceeding? Did you get all your questions answered? Did the two of you settle things at all?


The end came up very abruptly. I don’t exactly recall where we left it. Other than the fact that she wanted to focus on improving my relationship with my wife and kids.

dianthus wrote:
At worst, it sounds like she has a dismissive attitude. You told her exactly what you are looking for and what you want to work on, and she redirected you to something that is a lesser priority. Also I don't think it is valid to assume that improving your relationships is going to help with your anxiety and depression. It is more likely the other way around, your relationships will improve as a by-product of treating your anxiety and depression and coping better with being out of work.


I am beginning to think that therapy is not going to help me. Then again, it does give me something new to write about. Which is always nice. LOL.



Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

26 Feb 2014, 11:39 pm

btbnnyr wrote:
If the scores on the tests are the same and the answers to the questionnaires are the same, and this psych doesn't see a big difference in your behavior than the other psych, and of course your childhood history is the same, and so is your current life, then what is the point of another psych signing off on a second diagnosis when you already have a first diagnosis that was thorough and legit?

Are you worried that you are misdiagnosed or that you are not "autistic enough" based on what you read from other people on WP?


btbnnyr – These are some really good questions. I had to really think a lot about this...

I suppose, mostly because the people I have told about the diagnosis (my parents, siblings, an uncle, a cousin and 2 former work colleagues) have all expressed doubts. The uncle is a Psychologist (though he is not too familiar with autism). The cousin is a Doctor who works in an autism research center.

That coupled with the fact that I seem much more high functioning than others in WP (being married, having kids, survived the workplace for 25 years). Yeah, I realize that my wife made many compromises to put up with me. And, she mostly raised the kids. But still.

Plus the fact that I am a born skeptic.



btbnnyr
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 18 May 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,359
Location: Lost Angleles Carmen Santiago

27 Feb 2014, 12:46 am

Amongst my autistic research participants, all the people age 45+ are married, with kids, and employed fulltime unless they are homemaker.


_________________
Drain and plane and grain and blain your brain, and then again,
Propane and butane out of the gas main, your blain shall sustain!


Schneekugel
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 18 Jul 2012
Age: 45
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,612

27 Feb 2014, 4:19 am

You wrote that you wanted to figure out, how to make your life with your wife and your kid better, the therapist tells you that he wants to focus on that: I dont see the problem?

I think you bother around too much about separating all your issues, when normally all this issues are linked to each other. If you are depressive and suffer from anxiety, its normal that your life with your wife and kid will suffer from that. So if she says, she will work on you to enhance that, then dealing with the effect of depression and anxiety on your family-life, will as well have an impact on that.

Therapy is not about pushing a few certain switches, but to help you to change your oppinions and believings, that are causing you to be the way you actually are = suffering. And this changes in oppinions, will affect every part of your life, be it work, family, ...



Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

27 Feb 2014, 10:00 pm

Schneekugel - Thanks for your reply.

Schneekugel wrote:
You wrote that you wanted to figure out, how to make your life with your wife and your kid better, the therapist tells you that he wants to focus on that: I dont see the problem?


I did. But, I did put that as priority #4. Which (to me) means we may get there in several months. Or maybe never. After all, I don't plan to do this forever (as it certainly is not cheap).

Schneekugel wrote:
I think you bother around too much about separating all your issues, when normally all this issues are linked to each other. If you are depressive and suffer from anxiety, its normal that your life with your wife and kid will suffer from that. So if she says, she will work on you to enhance that, then dealing with the effect of depression and anxiety on your family-life, will as well have an impact on that.


So, my relationship with my wife and kids -- from my perspective -- is not that bad. I added it to the list, because I figured that it's something that could always be improved. But, it is not a cause of my consternation. And improving it will not resolve the higher order items. Hence the reason for prioritization. Now, if she had said what you said, about dealing first with sadness/anxiety, then I wouldn’t be concerned. But that’s not what she said.

I think dianthus said it best...

dianthus wrote:
Also I don't think it is valid to assume that improving your relationships is going to help with your anxiety and depression. It is more likely the other way around, your relationships will improve as a by-product of treating your anxiety and depression and coping better with being out of work.


Schneekugel wrote:
Therapy is not about pushing a few certain switches, but to help you to change your oppinions and believings, that are causing you to be the way you actually are = suffering. And this changes in oppinions, will affect every part of your life, be it work, family, ...


Interesting. Not certain why, but this isn't exactly what I was expecting (out of therapy). Honestly, I have no idea what I was expecting. I suppose I was simply hoping to better understand myself. I was hoping to figure out how to better cope, the next time I am unemployed (which I know will happen, it’s just a matter of when). As this changed my pervasive sadness to deep depression. I was hoping to figure out how to better maneuver in life, knowing I have Aspergers (assuming it is confirmed – LOL).

I am now thinking I should do what someone else recently recommended. Just curl up and read more books on the topic (of Aspergers, Anxiety, Depression, etc.).



tall-p
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 25 Dec 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,155

28 Feb 2014, 3:07 am

Rocket123 wrote:
Am I approaching this wrong?

My two cents is that you showed up at the psychologist's office. A psychologist's job is to basically "have a relationship" with the PATIENT. And eventually insights come to the patient because of the relationshipThe patient has problems. Patients show up everyday at thousands and thousands of psychologist's every day. So here you are, one of these patients, and you show up for your first appointment with:

Quote:
- A 3-page document I wrote last year describing why I was seeking a diagnosis
- A 33-page document I wrote last year describing "stuff" that seemed to represent my symptoms of Aspergers
- A 6 page intake questionnaire, that I completed before getting my Aspergers diagnosis
- A 20 page diagnosis report, completed by the Psychologist who diagnosed me

How often do you think new patients show up with this ^^?

Plus, you present in the first "hour" that you want to talk about...
Quote:
My goals of seeing someone was (in order of priority):
#1. I wanted a second opinion on the original diagnosis
#2. I wanted to figure out how to better deal with anxiety and occasional depression
#3. I wanted to figure out to cope better, the next time I am out of work (which will probably happen within the next 4-9 months)
#4. I wanted to figure out how to make my life with my wife, daughters better

She says that she doesn't care about YOUR priorities and she wants to talk about #4... and you think... "I am now wondering if this is all simply a waste of my time/money? That this person is not going to help me (with my top 3 goals)."I do not like relying on any one person's opinion." Or, "Just curl up and read more books on the topic (of Aspergers, Anxiety, Depression, etc.).?

I mean really Rocket doesnt it sorta seem like you want to control the whole show... you have it all figured out... you know what you need well... pretty much about everything? You know that she needs to read all these documents that you have brought, and you want to talk about them... and about how scary it is when you lose your job... and get anxious or depressed. But wait... isn't it possible if you don't want to talk about your relationship with your wife and daughter (and therapist... female therapist) that these relationships, and maybe your relationships are the problem?


_________________
Everything is falling.


Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

28 Feb 2014, 4:21 am

Tall-p – Thanks for your reply.

tall-p wrote:
My two cents is that you showed up at the psychologist's office. A psychologist's job is to basically "have a relationship" with the PATIENT. And eventually insights come to the patient because of the relationship.


This is good insight. Certainly, I want to expose the Psychologist to what’s going on in my head. Which is why I provided her with this information.

tall-p wrote:
So here you are, one of these patients, and you show up for your first appointment with:

Quote:
- A 3-page document I wrote last year describing why I was seeking a diagnosis
- A 33-page document I wrote last year describing "stuff" that seemed to represent my symptoms of Aspergers
- A 6 page intake questionnaire, that I completed before getting my Aspergers diagnosis
- A 20 page diagnosis report, completed by the Psychologist who diagnosed me

How often do you think new patients show up with this ^^?


I imagine not too often. Then again, the way I see it, it’s a quick start guide. It helped me introduce myself to her. During our first session, I walked her through the “discovery” process that I have gone through during the past 16 months to get where I am today. That process included the creation of those documents. As I told my story, I showed how those documents fit into this journey.

tall-p wrote:
I mean really Rocket doesnt it sorta seem like you want to control the whole show...


Of course. That’s part of who I am. Also, I wanted to be as organized as possible. So, I didn’t waste valuable (and expensive) time. I never intended this to be a long-term thing. I entered into this with a specific set of things I wanted to discuss and understand. She is an expert. I figured I was paying to get some of her expertise.

Perhaps, what you are getting at, is that I am approaching this thing incorrectly. Which is very possible. The last time I was in therapy was ~ 30 years ago. It was during a very dark period of my life. The therapy lasted 4 years. I exited from therapy in a better place. But, I attribute that simply to the passage of time, rather than anything the Psychologist did. I have no intention of doing that again.

tall-p wrote:
you have it all figured out... you know what you need well... pretty much about everything


No. Not at all. Though, I know why I decided to start therapy. I wouldn’t have started without having a specific set of goals.

tall-p wrote:
But wait... isn't it possible if you don't want to talk about your relationship with your wife and daughter (and therapist... female therapist) that these relationships, and maybe your relationships are the problem?


You are probably right (that relationships are a problem in my life). Particularly, from a neurotypical perspective. After all, I don’t have a lot of friends. And, I am not very close to people in my family (outside my wife and daughters). I have been a somewhat of a loner most of my life. In fact, when I was going through my diagnosis, I was thinking there was a chance that I might be diagnosed with schizoid personality disorder. I guess I didn't have the symptoms.

In any event, thanks for your comments. It really helps me think this through. Also, now that you mention it, maybe choosing a female therapist was a bad idea.



tall-p
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 25 Dec 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,155

28 Feb 2014, 12:10 pm

Rocket123 wrote:
Also, now that you mention it, maybe choosing a female therapist was a bad idea.

My little point is that chances are that you don't know what you need, or who you are, or what your problems really are... AND, you chose a woman psychologist because that is what you need. Also, you have had one visit, and are looking everywhere for a reason to quit. This is called resistance in psychobabble.


_________________
Everything is falling.


Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

28 Feb 2014, 3:00 pm

tall-p wrote:
My little point is that chances are that you don't know what you need, or who you are, or what your problems really are... AND, you chose a woman psychologist because that is what you need. Also, you have had one visit, and are looking everywhere for a reason to quit. This is called resistance in psychobabble.


You are correct. I am still trying to figure out what I need, who I am, what my problems really are. This is why I spent so much time creating all these documents, frequenting WP and writing in my journal (which is now > 250 typed pages in 8 pt font). I consider all of this my journey of self-discovery. It's not a new journey. I have been on it since I was younger (and was trying to actually understand why I was so different). But, I have so much more clarity now, after spending the past 16 months reading psychology books (on anxiety, depression, Aspergers, personality disorders, etc), watching lectures, taking psychology classes (from Yale, UCB, etc.), etc.

Anyhow, I spent some time discussing this with my wife this morning. We had discussed it prior to starting therapy. My wife actually is a therapist, counseling teens. She has pretty much been my therapist for the past 16 or so months (from the time I first learned of Aspergers). And, even before that (i.e. the times I became depressed about my general lack of direction). And, she does supports me going to therapy. Though, as she has said multiple times, she cannot be my therapist 24x7. As she tells me often, “Rocket, you are a lucky man [to have me as a wife]”. And, I am.

In any event, I appreciate your thoughts. As it requires me to really question things. Question my assumptions. Question my objectives. Question everything. Thank you.



Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

04 Mar 2014, 10:18 pm

Well, I had my second session today and it went much, much better. Thank you everyone for your advice and thoughts. As this really helped me really think about what was important to me.

So, at the beginning of the session, the Psychologist mentioned that she had read the 3-page document (describing why I had originally sought a diagnosis), but had only skimmed through the actual diagnosis report.

Then, I reiterated my goals (which were slightly augmented from my original post) including:

#1. Getting a second opinion on the original diagnosis
#2. Figuring out how to better deal with anxiety and occasional depression
#3. Figuring out to cope better, the next time I am out of work (which will probably happen within the next 4-9 months)
#4. Figuring out how to maneuver in life, knowing I have Aspergers
#5. Figuring out how to make my life with my wife, daughters better
#6. Exploring why I felt inadequate as an adult

We spent the first several minutes discussing the first topic. And, I touched on all the key points that I had previously discussed in this thread. Then, we spoke about obsessions, anxiety and depression. Then, we discussed medications. At the end, she agreed it made sense to spend the entire next session talking about the work situation.

So, I walked out of the session feeling pretty good.



dianthus
Veteran
Veteran

Joined: 25 Nov 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,138

05 Mar 2014, 7:15 am

I'm glad this session went better for you!



tall-p
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 25 Dec 2010
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,155

05 Mar 2014, 8:34 pm

Rocket123 wrote:
...Then, we discussed medications. At the end, she agreed it made sense to spend the entire next session talking about the work situation.

So, I walked out of the session feeling pretty good.

So the medications is a big hangup for me... I have written here about them often. In my opinion once you start with the meds then everything changes. The meds are "supposed to" ease one's anxieties and depressions... all bad feelings. The question becomes, "How are the meds working?" "Are the meds doing their job?" The sessions become shorter as the meds solve all your problems, and eventually the appointments are for 15 minutes once a month to tweak the doses. And you know what Timothy Leary said about dose?... "Dose is everything."

But I am glad you are happier with her. Where did the discussion on medications go?


_________________
Everything is falling.


Rocket123
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 15 Dec 2012
Age: 63
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,203
Location: Lost in Space

05 Mar 2014, 8:58 pm

tall-p wrote:
So the medications is a big hangup for me...Where did the discussion on medications go?


The medication thing came up, only because the summary of Diagnosis Report (which she had skimmed) included several recommendations – one of which was to “determine the appropriateness” of psycho medications.

I told her that I wasn’t interested in the medication path. As I was terrified of the side-effects. She too had concerns with medication and believed that therapy was a better solution (of course).