Page 2 of 2 [ 27 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2

GroovyDruid
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 384
Location: where I decide

04 Nov 2005, 8:58 pm

D-R-J wrote:
I think you've got it summed up perfectly here. I'm supposedly NT.. my kids and spouse are all AS. I have definitely had these feelings, trust me. I think every human being has had these feelings, no matter whether they fall on the spectrum or not or have other issues. It is part of our make up and is what has allowed us to survive on this planet.


I agree with some of this. Yes, NTs have these feelings, too. But the issue here is the threshold, and I think to say "everybody's got it" is to brush off a vital and little-discussed point, that the threshold for an Aspie can be frighteningly low. (That's why I started the thread.) For example:

Quote:
However in crowds, from noise and so forth, I do often feel urges creeping up, both urges to hurt myself (biting especially, and throwing myself sideways against walls) and to lash out.


I have felt this same way in crowds, and like NeatHumain, I have been stressed almost to the point of snapping by insignificant injustices like being wrongly charged, etc. I feel scared, belligerent, and alienated by things that any rational person would brush off as not worth the trouble (and I tell myself this, but it doesn't help the FEELINGS any, the obsession on the wrong that has been done to me...).

NTs don't do this, or they're not NT. Their threshold is far higher, or at least much different in some essential way.

The result: yes, everybody has a point where they say they're not going to take it anymore. But for an Aspie, that might not take very long and can be a very low. Then he or she goes bouncing off the walls and either hurts someone or even kills him, and a lot of people--particularly NTs--are left scratching their heads. "What brought that on?"

I guess what I'm exploring here is whether awareness in spite of the negative misunderstandings is worthwhile. We can say, "Everybody's got some anger," and "Aspies are just people and very peaceful," but this can confuse a lot of people as to the truth: we are very sensitive to stress in spite of ourselves. Our threshold for stress is low, so watch yourself here.

Of course, then one runs the risk of being labelled: "Watch out: he's got a disease, and he's a loose cannon."

I don't know what's right, but I do strongly believe that Aspie's tendency toward anger is brushed under the carpet far too often.



Last edited by GroovyDruid on 04 Nov 2005, 9:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.

GroovyDruid
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 384
Location: where I decide

04 Nov 2005, 9:24 pm

tdj0213 wrote:
I worry that I am trying to change my child and I don't really want to give him the impression that he needs to be fixed.


It's interesting: I've heard parents worry about this many times--including my own--and I've read psychologists agonizing over how to keep any AS or autistic child from feeling broken, but I've never heard an AS person complain about feeling like he or she needed to be fixed. In fact I've heard many talk about themselves and other Aspies as broken without any hint of bitterness or sarcasm.

I don't want to ruin a good solid worry (mothers do that; it's their job). :wink: But I would say that making him feel in need of fixing is the lesser of two evils compared to not giving your son all the information about himself.

See, MRIs have revealed that Aspies do most or all of their functioning on the analytical level, including trying to sort out emotions and people situations. (NTs have a whole hardwired setup for this that is mainly intuitive.)

So if he has the information to make sense of the differences he's gonna see in himself (and you can count on it that he'll see them all over), then he has a much better chance of solving the problems he faces well.

HOWEVER: giving him information does not mean evaluating him, which is very harsh coming from a parent. The difference would be between saying, "You're socially disabled, so you're going to strike out more. Don't do that," and "It's possible your tolerance for stress, noise, verbal abuse, and such things is different from that of the other kids. Tell me if you think it is, and we'll work out a way to handle it so that you're happy and comfortable."

Then he can come to you when he wants to deck somebody. He'll know for sure his back's not to the wall. Maybe you can discuss how you feel in social situations as an NT, to help explain the behaviors he sees but doesn't understand. Just some ideas.

:!: But most of all, make sure he gets the info he needs. Otherwise, he can't possibly deal with a world wired differently from himself.



monastic
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 13 Aug 2004
Gender: Female
Posts: 724
Location: Indiana

04 Nov 2005, 9:29 pm

Quote:
I guess what I'm exploring here is whether awareness in spite of the negative misunderstandings is worthwhile. We can say, "Everybody's got some anger," and "Aspies are just people and very peaceful," but this can confuse a lot of people as to the truth: we are very sensitive to stress in spite of ourselves. Our threshold for stress is low, so watch yourself here.

Of course, then one runs the risk of being labelled: "Watch out: he's got a disease, and he's a loose cannon."

I don't know what's right, but I do strongly believe that Aspie's tendency toward anger is brushed under the carpet far too often.


Evidently the Autistics you are in contact with are nothing like my Autie friends and My very own family members. Yes our stress level is low but no, when we overload we are more apt to be sick or have splitting headaches, you might even find us fleeing whatever has caused the overload or perhaps find us cowering in a corner somewhere totally detached from the excitement and activities going on around us. Violence is NOT our reaction to stressful situations.

I have no tolerance for those that like to depict us as dangerous animals that are just waiting to find a reason to "go off" like a bomb.
I won't say we don't get mad. I won't say we don't scream and yell and throw things. Because we are passionately against injustice does NOT mean we have a potential to kill people.

I say I have no tolerance for those that like to depict us as dangerous animals. When I say this, I do not feel a tendency to hurt those that see us this way. I will be blunt which may seem aggressive. The reality is, I will probably just stay as far away as I possibly can from those that see me in such a negative light.


_________________
Compressing the most words into the smallest ideas possible.

In times of universal deceit, telling the truth will be a revolutionary act. - George Orwell


Sarcastic_Name
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Mar 2005
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,593

04 Nov 2005, 11:39 pm

GroovyDruid wrote:
NeantHumain has a very lively discussion forum going about how he was arrested after throwing ketchup on a food service woman with whom he was irritated.

William Freund just shot two people. :(

I have never been arrested, and I've never shot or assaulted anyone. But to be perfectly honest, when I read about both these incidents, my reaction based on my own experiences was, "I understand on some level why both did what they did."

I would like to know whether I'm alone here, or whether other Aspies feel the same way. :?:

For example: before I was diagnosed, I often felt a good deal of anger bottled up in me. I have no other conditions other than AS, but that was enough. I would get into situations in which I felt threatened or put on the spot, and I would be unable to get help or express myself. I would be bullied, or belittled, and I couldn't spew back the vitrol or punches than any reasonably glib NT of my intelligence level would have shot back, or ask someone for assistance. The pressure would reach a point where I would fantasize about getting the drop on and killing those responsible for my misery, either peers or authority figures. Even a simple misunderstanding that I couldn't correct could build into these fantasies.

No one who knows me would characterize me as an aggressive person at all. I trap spiders and take them outside rather than squash them, for Pete's sake. But man, I would plan in detail the untimely death of these villians who were apparently trying to subvert my existence. I truly felt my life was threatened, and I often resolved to stop the attack by guerilla action if it came to that. (It of course never did, and I learned about my condition and got tremendous relief that way....)

On one occassion when I was around twelve I lashed out. A particularly mean-spirited boy in my youth group, Mr. Nasty, would stand next to me and pinch me when no adult was looking, or punch me in the arm and give me ugly blue bruises, then laugh. He somehow knew I wouldn't be able to ask for help (He had what I call as**ole radar, which zeros in on victims). Well, he grabbed a flap of my skin on the back of my arm and twisted, and I uncorked on him. I jumped him instantly and slapped him up something good. They had to pull us apart, and I was on top going to town. I felt very guilty about that. I knew I had broken the rules, and I was always so careful about following the rules. But the point was, I felt like I had run out of options. (Side note: Mr. Nasty never touched me ever again.)

Perhaps I'm just a former Angry Young Man on a tangent, but I think this is important to discuss. We've all bemoaned at length the violence that has happened invovling our AS brethren and sworn that it is anomalous. We don't wish to be seen as dangerous or unpredictable people, and that makes sense. Under unstressed conditions, Aspies I think are among the most peaceful of human beings. But is this really the whole truth? Should we risk acknowledging this darker side, the side that becomes stressed easily and in some cases lashes out to perpetrate regretable damage?

(I know Mr. Nasty wished he'd have known it...) :D


Aren't we all that way?


_________________
Hello.


PhoenixKitten
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 13 Jun 2005
Age: 40
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,609
Location: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

05 Nov 2005, 12:34 am

Pardon me if I'm splitting hairs, but it seems to me that it's not so much that Aspies are more prone to violence as much as it is that Aspies find more things more frustrating than your average NT, and have less coping resources, as we can find it difficult to communicate (kinda makes it hard to 'talk about your problems' eh?).


_________________
...though fire may burn & flames envelop me, I will arise from the ashes...


hidoko
Tufted Titmouse
Tufted Titmouse

User avatar

Joined: 2 Nov 2005
Gender: Female
Posts: 43
Location: Singapore

05 Nov 2005, 8:01 am

PhoenixKitten wrote:
Pardon me if I'm splitting hairs, but it seems to me that it's not so much that Aspies are more prone to violence as much as it is that Aspies find more things more frustrating than your average NT, and have less coping resources, as we can find it difficult to communicate (kinda makes it hard to 'talk about your problems' eh?).


Ditto. I hardly lash out at people and when I am really overloaded I don't even stim - I just zombie out. (That scares people who care into s**t, but at least nobody's dying.)

Like how some NTs will just fly into a rage at the slightest thing and some NTs have more patience. It's the same thing. Different people have different personalities regardless of their neurological wiring.


_________________
Deskmonkey by day, superhero by night.
With my spandex cape and undies I take flight.


GroovyDruid
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 384
Location: where I decide

05 Nov 2005, 3:05 pm

Sarcastic_Name wrote:
Aren't we all that way?


It's not quite clear: which "way" are you referring to? And which "we" are you referring to? Aspies, human beings...? :?:


_________________
Whatever you can do,
Or dream you can do,
Begin it.
Boldness has genius,
Power and magic in it.

--Goethe


GroovyDruid
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 384
Location: where I decide

05 Nov 2005, 3:41 pm

monastic wrote:
Evidently the Autistics you are in contact with are nothing like my Autie friends and My very own family members. Yes our stress level is low but no, when we overload we are more apt to be sick or have splitting headaches, you might even find us fleeing whatever has caused the overload or perhaps find us cowering in a corner somewhere totally detached from the excitement and activities going on around us. Violence is NOT our reaction to stressful situations.


I, too, usually get internally upset, a stomach ache, or withdraw in reaction to stress and become non-responsive. That's the norm for me. I rarely feel violently defensive from the get-go.

I wrote about my altercation with Mr. Nasty--the only time I have ever physically attacked another human being--in the hopes of encouraging others to share their stories, which can be embarrassing and upsetting, because (at least for me) it was terrifying and made me very ashamed of myself, since I knew how wrong it was. Same thing with the ideation of snapping and killing people.

:?: Now I'm very curious: are you saying you and your family/friends never feel frustrated, violent, or aggressive when pressured or threatened by people, sometimes over many reoccurrances, and feel a strong inclination to rash action? (REGARDLESS OF WHETHER YOU ACT ON THOSE IMPULSES. The topic here is whether we share the ideations of these feelings as a group, not whether we act on them.) Down below you mention something about throwing things and getting angry, so I'd like to clear that up.


monastic wrote:
I have no tolerance for those that like to depict us as dangerous animals that are just waiting to find a reason to "go off" like a bomb.
I won't say we don't get mad. I won't say we don't scream and yell and throw things. Because we are passionately against injustice does NOT mean we have a potential to kill people.

I say I have no tolerance for those that like to depict us as dangerous animals. When I say this, I do not feel a tendency to hurt those that see us this way. I will be blunt which may seem aggressive. The reality is, I will probably just stay as far away as I possibly can from those that see me in such a negative light.


This is interesting: I haven't run into any situations in which people have thought me a dangerous or unpredictable person. I would like to know more about people treating you or your friends this way. Since you say you have no patience with them, you've clearly had some experiences I have not. I'd like to know about them, os that I'm prepared when I or my children do.

Also, do you feel their is some particular reason/source of people who like to portray us like dangerous animals?


_________________
Whatever you can do,
Or dream you can do,
Begin it.
Boldness has genius,
Power and magic in it.

--Goethe


Sarcastic_Name
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Mar 2005
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,593

06 Nov 2005, 3:00 pm

GroovyDruid wrote:
Sarcastic_Name wrote:
Aren't we all that way?


It's not quite clear: which "way" are you referring to? And which "we" are you referring to? Aspies, human beings...? :?:


Oh, human beings in general. I always thought something like this was human nature.


_________________
Hello.


GroovyDruid
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Oct 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 384
Location: where I decide

06 Nov 2005, 3:47 pm

Sarcastic_Name wrote:
Oh, human beings in general. I always thought something like this was human nature.


I see. Yes. I think it definitely is. NT kids get angry, think of lashing out or fantisizing about killing their enemies, etc. But I see a difference in the mechanism. I think PhoenixKitten put it well:

Quote:
Pardon me if I'm splitting hairs, but it seems to me that it's not so much that Aspies are more prone to violence as much as it is that Aspies find more things more frustrating than your average NT, and have less coping resources, as we can find it difficult to communicate (kinda makes it hard to 'talk about your problems' eh?).


I am fascinated with where this line is and how we might help younger Aspies especially to keep from getting into trouble spots. It can have such tragic results.


_________________
Whatever you can do,
Or dream you can do,
Begin it.
Boldness has genius,
Power and magic in it.

--Goethe


tdj0213
Emu Egg
Emu Egg

User avatar

Joined: 3 Nov 2005
Gender: Female
Posts: 4
Location: Atlanta, GA

06 Nov 2005, 6:23 pm

I, too, would like to know where the line is drawn so we can be more aware of the triggers that set our 13 year old son off. He seems much more edgy these days and will have a flare up over nothing. I think he is stressed in general, probably hormones and school pressures combined. Sometimes I am not sure if it is Asperger's or ADHD (he has both). I don't want to see him reach a point where someone gets hurt. He hasn't really lashed out at anyone, but has been known to throw things including books and desks. These were extremes, they don't happen often, but he does get up and walk out of class and also runs out of his school. He can go for up to an hour where he makes no eye contact or talks to anyone, he will be emotionally shut down. This is hard in the school setting (he is in 8th grade) where all the other kids are thinking he is "wierd" and the teachers just don't want to have to deal with it. He is in regular education classes because he is so smart, but it seems the larger classes are part of where his stress is coming from. In our area, the only way he could be in smaller classes is if he is in with lower functioning special education students.

He also struggles with writing, so any assignment just sends him over the edge. Now we have a motivation problem, he isn't even trying. I figure he doesn't have the desire to try if he can't do it perfectly and there are so many obstacles with the AS/ADHD and LD in writing. We wonder what kind of placement to put him in high school next year. We don't want him to quit school or go off on someone when his stress level peaks out. We see he has potential, but all these challenges make it hard to know which direction to take.

Has anyone here experienced any of this? What did you do?

Thanks... I do love my son and when he hurts, I hurt too!