Sweetleaf wrote:
Verdandi wrote:
James Holmes is about as likely to be autistic as he is to be a Martian. I also doubt he's bipolar or schizophrenic.
However, "normal" people don't go on shooting sprees. Someone does something like this, they are almost certainly diagnosable with something.
Anyways this is what gave me the impression you were implying mentally ill people are more likely than 'normal' people to do something like that.
General studies per the mentally ill indicate they are no more likely than the general population to be associated with violence, however there are exceptions to that general research among subgroups.
The issue has been studied specifically per rampage killings, and about half of the individuals studied were formally diagnosed mentally ill and often schizophrenic. Many were reported as receiving no treatment for their mental illnesses or were not taking their prescribed medications prior to the rampage killings.
http://www.nytimes.com/2000/04/13/opinion/a-closer-look-at-rampage-killings.htmlQuote:
A team of New York Times reporters and researchers, in examining the nature of these attacks and the individuals involved, compiled a detailed database on 100 such cases over the past 50 years. The series of articles published in The Times this week based on that research offered several new insights. Although such killings account for only one-tenth of 1 percent of all homicides, the series confirmed the public perception that they appear to be increasing. It also found that rampage killers share several traits. Most are better educated than typical murderers, are more likely to have military experience, and are far more likely to kill themselves.
Cultural influences on this group, such as violent entertainment, seemed to have little impact. Instead, the most common factor was serious mental health problems. About half had received formal diagnosis of mental illness, often schizophrenia. More than half made threats, and a third had histories of violent behavior. Many never received treatment for mental disorders or were not monitored to keep them on their medication. Most of their rampage attacks were not sudden, impulsive acts but the culmination of years of rage, depression and mental illness. Often the failure of families, co-workers and even therapists to deal with warning signs led to catastrophic consequences.
Even with greater care in spotting mental disturbance, there can never be a perfect system. But the other crucial factor in rampage killings, access to guns, can be affected through legislation and regulation. More than half the killers, including those with histories of hospitalization for mental illness, were able to buy guns easily. While federal law prohibits the sale of guns to those who have been involuntarily committed to a mental institution, most states do not conduct background checks on a purchaser's psychiatric history.
The more notable recent rampage killings have been carried out by young adult males, however the research that was done prior to the year 2000 indicates that most were middle age males.
Considering that his mother was a psychiatric nurse, it's not likely that an autism spectrum disorder would have gone undetected during Holmes youth. It is pretty obvious that he is a delusional individual, by any reasonable observation, regardless of what potential diagnosis may eventually be attached to those delusions.
It's not impossible that someone like him presenting the behavior he is currently presenting would have an autism spectrum disorder, as the ICD10 acknowledges that Aspergers is associated with psychotic breaks from reality in young adulthood, in some cases.
I think it is likely that the parents may be able to contribute more information to the authorities regarding his mental health, but the general public may not ever become aware of those details, if they are not presented as part of the case. If he wasn't drugged in the courtroom today, it appeared he was not sharing the same reality with the rest of the people in that room, nor was he making any attempt to hide it.