PhoenixKitten wrote:
Mmm cars... *drools* I'm afraid I'm one of those people who squeals when the sparks come off the jumper plugs! All the same, I have enough brains to know that the guy in the panel van at McDonalds was probably not the brightest bulb when he decided to pour cold water under the bonnet when it was smoking...

Can you say cracked head gasket?

No, but I can say cracked head. A sudden temp change can crack the metal head, but not the gasket.
However, you can blow a head gasket that way as the head can deform enough to allow the gasket to blow out- but the gasket isn't directly destroyed by cold vs hot.
It has also been my experience that the catastrophic effects of putting cold water in an overheating engine is largely bunk, as you fill engine coolant either through the overflow or the radiator fill- not the engine itself. The radiator is built to handle huge temp differentials, and should not have an issue with hot vs cold- that's its job.
The few minutes that elapses between filling the radiator and closing everything up, packing up the water container, and restarting the vehicle should be more than enough to largely equalize temps beyond what could cause damage.
The only way I can really see an issue here is if a person filled ice cold water into an overheated engine that was bone dry- and if they had overheated an engine until it was dry, it is very likely the damage is actually from that, not the water put in as a too little, too late gesture.
_________________
I am indeed a "proud aspie".
There are 10 kinds of people in the world- Those that understand binary, and those who don't.