idiocratik wrote:
Everyone tends to put image above substance. So, I don't think it's a matter of how nice you are, it's how "hot" you are. If you put a guy with tats and piercings, cool hair, and stylish clothing next to a guy who doesn't have any body mods, has normal hair, and a conservative wardrobe she'll most like choose the guy with tats. Attractive women want excitement in their lives, so if you look exciting that's what she'll go for. Then the guy turns out to be a jerkface, and they break up. You might be there to play the understanding "good friend", but she'll still go after who is more physically attractive. "Nice guys" tend to be much more conservative, and that isn't appealing.
I see you've assumed the man with the tats and piercings isn't a nice guy. There is no basis for that assumption. You have also assumed that nice guys tend to be more conservative. Again, no basis for that assumption. Nice guys come in all flavors. You can't tell by looking at somebody whether they are nice or not.
A nice guy is merely somebody who treats others with decency. This has nothing to do either with inherent looks or with style choices. And no- being unhiply dressed doesn't mean you aren't a jerk.