Which "musician" is worse: Justin Bieber or Rebecc

Post Reply New Topic

Personally, I think both of them suck as musicians. But if I had to choose, I would have to choose Rebecca Black as the worse musician. This is because it's her singing that makes Justin Bieber look like Eminem.

What do you guys think on this?

I honestly cant answer that, they are both just terrible.

I don't think they should even be called musicians!

Jenna Rose beats them both.

Who are Justin Bieber and Rebecca Black?

i donno who rebecca black is and i never heard justin bieber sing but i've seen him in commercials. he's kinda cute though

Justin Bieber by far. I actually feel sorry for Rebecca Black.

Justin Bieber

Never heard Rebecca Black's music, so I can't say anything if she is talented or not.

Friday is just talking about what shes doing that day. What car seat is she going to sit on. What the hell?

Rebecca Black isn't a musician, she's a rich kid.

Rebecca Black is the equivalent of Tay Zonday, an internet diamond in the rough passed around for giggles between too many people and eventually given enough attention for people to convince themselves that the popularity must definitely correlate to their talent and perceive the talent to be greater than it is. An opportunistic person in this position can make a lot of money in a short amount of time, but whether they realize the source of their sudden fame is the variable. Rebecca Black is at least wise enough to know that she isn't the next big thing and that the internet is having its joke, and so donated all proceeds of the song to a relief fund for Japan. That in itself makes her a better person to me than to have an enormous self-indulgent career at such a young age. He's shooting fish in a barrel.

Tay Zonday is a great person who actually wrote he songs. From what I hear Rebecca Black doesnt write her own songs. Tay is great, black is not.

I will not discredit his very real passion for making music and songwriting, and you are completely right on that point.

I can sing better with laryngytis and write better songs in my sleep.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CD2LRROpph0[/youtube]

I won't vote in this poll because Rebecca only released that one song & it's kind of hard for me to form a good opinion about her music based only on that. Song is quite catchy but I'm upset that that vid is a lot like Miranda Cosgrove's, Dancing Crazy & gets a lot more attention than Dancing Crazy

Well, at least Bieber can take a tone... Black relies entirely on autotune.