Cyberman wrote:
Vietnam War: America lost, and had no real justification for being there anyway (though there already have been a few Vietnam shooters)
Korean War: stalemate
All wars before World War 2: most tactics and weapons were too primitive for an enjoyable shooter (no hand-held automatic weapons)
So a shooter can only exist if America was a) in it or b) won?
COD3 has a sequence where you use a Welrod... a single shot pistol with a hand screwing breech. I spent most of the game using the Enfields because accuracy on a Thompson is for s**t. SMG is NOT the be all and end all, and rate of fire is a good way of increasing tension in a game. Imagine how much more tense the Chernobyl Fairground rush would be if you could only fire three rounds a minute...
Or take WW1.. contrary to ill-educated popular belief, that conflict was not just 5 years of sitting in a muddy hole followed by ten minutes of getting shelled into oblivion, then made to walk into certain death. You could start by playing Gavrilo Princip, Arch Duke Ferdinand's assassin. Perhaps a level involving Naval Actions? Cavalry and Infantry skirmish at the outbreak of war... trench raiding across No Man's Land.. or maybe Storming the beach at Gallipoli.. or fighting with German OstAfrika Askaris? Then there's being a sniper, or even just taking on a rush (because if there is one thing that had a lot of Rushes, its WW1. Then there's the tank parts.. racing to keep up with a formation of Whippets, or duelling with Forward Batteries in a Mark 1. How about the (genuine and real) action by a crippled Mark 1 crew fighting off the Germans for near three days, with dwindling ammunition? Maybe you could go spotting for the Artillery in a biplane? (Like the Spectre sequence in COD4)... I dunno.. go read a book.. there is a shedload of material. Maybe you could even sit in a dugout and write poetry as a minigame....
Try an earlier period. Try patrolling Waziristan in a Rolls Royce Armoured Car, being sniped at by leery Muslim tribesmen. Take on the hostile tribes of the African Interior with a Martini Henry breech-loading rifle... Charge the Russian guns at Balaclava with the Light Brigade.
And that's just the actual WARS.
This is why the Doctor always beat the Cybermen.. lack of imagination. Be inspired already. Go look these things up, then imagine them as FPS.
_________________
"There is a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart,
that you can't take part" [Mario Savo, 1964]