Dislike of Metal
Sweetleaf
Veteran
Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 34
Gender: Female
Posts: 34,539
Location: Somewhere in Colorado
And on the topic of Dynamic Range:
For some genres, a low dynamic range may be a part of the sound, but I find it ruins most music.
A lot of modern productions are over-compression their music, thus getting rid of ALL the dynamics, and making it sound so loud, the actual instruments and such sound distorted and damaged.
This has affected rock and metal negatively in modern albums, but the worst victims of it are pop music and electronic - the 'loudness wars' have KILLED electronic. If you dislike mainstream electronic, just know I do as well, as most of it is very poorly produced and puts emphasis on LOUDNESS over anything else.
It's all quantity now, not quality.
I avoid over-compressing my stuff in my own productions. The average electronic song I hear now, comes up with a dynamic range of about 4-6. A few retro classics from the '90s come up with anywhere from 8-12.
A recent song I completed? 16, so I must be doing something right.
Though some metal do use it for artistic purposes - overdriving the amp, etc. But this still does crush the dynamic range, causing a lack of variation in sound levels, something that causes listener fatigue.
Though most people don't usually notice when listening, music with higher dynamic ranges tends to simply sound more pleasant to most ears.
Some recent very successful songs with a decent amount of dynamic range are Get Lucky - Daft Punk and Uptown Funk - Bruno Mars.
Listen to these tracks again and you may be able to hear that they sound more 'dramatic', that's because they have more dynamic range.
mr_bigmouth_502
Veteran
Joined: 12 Dec 2013
Age: 30
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 7,028
Location: Alberta, Canada
For some genres, a low dynamic range may be a part of the sound, but I find it ruins most music.
A lot of modern productions are over-compression their music, thus getting rid of ALL the dynamics, and making it sound so loud, the actual instruments and such sound distorted and damaged.
This has affected rock and metal negatively in modern albums, but the worst victims of it are pop music and electronic - the 'loudness wars' have KILLED electronic. If you dislike mainstream electronic, just know I do as well, as most of it is very poorly produced and puts emphasis on LOUDNESS over anything else.
It's all quantity now, not quality.
I avoid over-compressing my stuff in my own productions. The average electronic song I hear now, comes up with a dynamic range of about 4-6. A few retro classics from the '90s come up with anywhere from 8-12.
A recent song I completed? 16, so I must be doing something right.
Though some metal do use it for artistic purposes - overdriving the amp, etc. But this still does crush the dynamic range, causing a lack of variation in sound levels, something that causes listener fatigue.
Though most people don't usually notice when listening, music with higher dynamic ranges tends to simply sound more pleasant to most ears.
Some recent very successful songs with a decent amount of dynamic range are Get Lucky - Daft Punk and Uptown Funk - Bruno Mars.
Listen to these tracks again and you may be able to hear that they sound more 'dramatic', that's because they have more dynamic range.
Good explanation. And I agree, electronic music has probably been the biggest victim of the loudness war. It's a real shame, because synth music can be beautiful if you allow for some dynamic range. Just look at Aphex Twin, or Jean Michel Jarre, or early Depeche Mode.
Overcompression can work well though if you're looking for a dark, aggressive sound. I mean, I don't think Nine Inch Nails' Broken EP would have been nearly the same if they didn't distort the crap out of everything, particularly the guitars. I absolutely adore the guitar sound on that EP.
_________________
Every day is exactly the same...
mr_bigmouth_502
Veteran
Joined: 12 Dec 2013
Age: 30
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 7,028
Location: Alberta, Canada
There are plenty of metal bands out there that use clean, melodic vocals (Iron Maiden is a great example), but I'm not sure of any that use acoustic guitars. Acid Bath, normally a very harsh sounding band, have done a couple of ballads with clean vocals and undistorted guitars, those being "Dead Girl" and "The Bones of Baby Dolls". "Scream of the Butterfly" sort of fits too, as it has clean vocals and guitars, though it's actually pretty heavy and it even features double-kick drumming.
Scream of the Butterfly: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2q3nnm
Videos of their songs, at least the album versions, are hard to find on YouTube since their record label really, really likes taking them down.
_________________
Every day is exactly the same...
Actually I like metal, rock, punk, thrash, etc guitar music.
In fact my favorite guitar veteran legend is Space Ace
But sadly because I cannot play the guitar
So I got more to non-guitar stuff..
Last edited by MannyBoo on 28 Feb 2016, 10:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
But sadly because I cannot play the guitar
So I fell more to non-guitar stuff
To be frank, synthpop with early analog synths is music that I connect to most with. I just heard guitar sounds far too much that they no longer give me any experience as an analog synth would. I detest guitar music.
_________________
Sebastian
"Don't forget to floss." - Darkwing Duck
Interestingly, I actually hate overly positive music, because I find it to be annoying, and I hate having other people's happiness shoved in my face. I tend to prefer music that focuses on negative emotions like anger and suffering, since I can better relate to them.
Also, screamo is not metal. Sorry, it's just something that annoys me, when people call metal "screamo", because the two have nothing to do with one another.
Ughh not for me. If a song is depressing it makes upset and sad.
Songs like 'Look into my father's eyes' and 'Cats in the cradle' just make want to jump off a building.
Probably since my dad passed away
_________________
Sebastian
"Don't forget to floss." - Darkwing Duck